Who is right regarding the proper use of an oil filter wrench during an oil change?

Using an oil filter wrench properly is essential for effectively changing oil and ensuring that the oil filter is removed without damaging the filter or surrounding components. Both individuals in the scenario likely utilize the correct technique, which might include ensuring a secure grip on the filter and applying consistent, even pressure when turning the filter. This method helps avoid stripping the filter or making it overly tight, which can complicate future oil changes.

Additionally, employing an oil filter wrench allows for easier removal of a filter that may be stuck due to overtightening or aging. It's also important to note that the tool should be properly matched to the size and shape of the oil filter to prevent slippage while in use. Understanding the significance of proper technique and the correct use of tools in this context is vital to maintaining the integrity of the engine and its components during a routine oil change and promotes effective maintenance practices.